All Comparisons

Payrollix vs Wave Payroll

Wave Payroll is the cheapest credible name-brand payroll. In April 2025 Wave consolidated to a single national plan at $40/mo + $6/employee with tax filing in all 50 states (via partnership with Check). For a one-business owner who already uses Wave's free accounting software, it is genuinely the right answer at small scale. For an accounting firm, the per-company base × N clients math is the same problem you have with every non-bureau competitor — plus Wave does not have an accountant-channel program at all.

Pricing Comparison

Payrollix

$12/client/mo flat. 5 employees included; $2/mo each additional.

Wave Payroll

$40/mo base + $6/employee per company. (Previously $20 in self-service states / $35 in tax-service states; consolidated April 2025.)

50 clients × 6 employees on Wave: $40×50 + $6×6×50 = $2,000 + $1,800 = $3,800/mo. Payrollix: ~$700/mo. Annual delta: ~$37,200.

Feature Comparison

FeaturePayrollixWave Payroll
Per-client flat pricing$12/client$40 base × N clients
Accountant programNativeNo accountant tier
Multi-client dashboardNative
Tax filing coverage50 states + federal MeF in-house50 states via Check partnership
IRS e-filingDirect MeF (in-house)Via Check / Wave
W-2 / 1099 generationBatch + 4-year S3 archiveIncluded
Mobile app (iOS + Android)Employee + client portalsWave employee app (basic)
Dedicated client portal
Geofencing time trackingBuilt-in
Bookkeeping includedWave Accounting (free tier exists)
Free invoicing toolIncluded (Wave Invoicing free)
Single tool for accounting + payroll for sole proprietorsNoYes (integrated)
Customer count / brand recognitionNew (2025)~4M small businesses using Wave (free + paid)
QuickBooks / XeroBidirectionalWave-only by design
Onboarding packet (8655 + state POAs)One e-signPiecemeal
API accessAgency+

Why Choose Payrollix

Designed for accountants running many clients; Wave isn't
In-house IRS MeF — Wave routes through a third-party (Check)
iOS + Android apps for both employees and clients
Integrations into the broader accounting ecosystem (QBO, Xero, Odoo, Sage)
Built-in geofencing time tracking
Dedicated client portal

Wave Payroll Limitations

No accountant-channel pricing or multi-client dashboard
Per-company $40 base multiplied across the client list
Tax filing is via Check partnership, not directly with the IRS
Wave is a Wave-ecosystem product — limited interop
Honest concession: if your client wants free invoicing + cheap payroll in one tool, Wave's integrated accounting is genuinely useful

Ready to switch from Wave Payroll?

Start your 14-day free trial. We'll help you migrate your data.